[Bug] CCleaner 3.18.1707 exclusion-rule override

[applepi]

Application: CCleaner 3.18.1707

OS: Windows XP Pro (SP3)

 

Bug: An inclusion-rule takes precedence over an exlusion-rule when the exclusion-rule is applied to a folder that does not contain any files or sub-folders.

 

Steps to reproduce:

1. Create a root folder anywhere. (e.g. C:\MY_ROOT_FOLDER\)

2. Create a file within the root folder. (e.g. C:\MY_ROOT_FOLDER\WITHIN_ROOT.txt)

3. Create a sub-folder within the root folder. (e.g. C:\MY_ROOT_FOLDER\MY_SUB_FOLDER\)

4. Create a file within the sub-folder. (e.g. C:\MY_ROOT_FOLDER\MY_SUB_FOLDER\WITHIN_SUB.txt)

 

The folder structure resembles the following:

 

C:\MY_ROOT_FOLDER\
|
+---WITHIN_ROOT.txt
|
+---C:\MY_ROOT_FOLDER\MY_SUB_FOLDER\
|
+---WITHIN_SUB.txt

 

5. Inside CCleaner, create an exclusion-rule for "C:\MY_ROOT_FOLDER\MY_SUB_FOLDER\"

- Check "Drive or Folder"

- Check "All Files" (under File Types)

 

6. Inside CCleaner, create an inclusion-rule for "C:\MY_ROOT_FOLDER\"

- Check "Drive or Folder"

- Check "All Files" (under File Types)

- Select "Include files and subfolders"

 

The way the rules are intended to be setup is that I want CCleaner to remove any file or sub-folder that appears under "C:\MY_ROOT_FOLDER\", however, I want "C:\MY_ROOT_FOLDER\MY_SUB_FOLDER\" to be protected from removal whether or not it contains a file or any sub-folders below it.

 

So let's run CCleaner with these rules. Great! It seemingly worked as it should. It did not remove "C:\MY_ROOT_FOLDER\MY_SUB_FOLDER\" or the text file contained within it.

 

Now, lets see how the rules perform if we trash "WITHIN_SUB.txt" making "C:\MY_ROOT_FOLDER\MY_SUB_FOLDER\" empty. So I manually remove "WITHIN_SUB.txt" making sure "C:\MY_ROOT_FOLDER\MY_SUB_FOLDER\" is indeed empty. While the folder *is* empty I'm hoping the exclusion-rule will protect it from being removed.

 

So let's run CCleaner again. This time, "C:\MY_ROOT_FOLDER\MY_SUB_FOLDER\" gets removed.

 

The exclusion-rule has failed me and the inclusion-rule for the parent folder took precedence and removed this folder anyway. The exclusion-rule only seems to be ignored if there are no files or sub-folders inside of "C:\MY_ROOT_FOLDER\MY_SUB_FOLDER\".

 

What I'd like to see: If an exclusion-rule is setup for a folder, don't allow for the folder's removal (via inclusive-rules) regardless of whether or not it contains any files or sub-folders.

[Guest MrT]

Thanks, we'll look into this.

[Guest MrT]

You have to create an exclusion for the folder itself:

 

D:\MY_ROOT_FOLDER\MY_SUB_FOLDER

or

for example using wildcards:

D:\MY_ROOT_FOLDER\*FOLDER