Spybot Search & Destroy or Microsoft Anti Spyware? Options

[englishmen]

For anti spyware protection i currently have SpywareBlaster, Ad-ware SE Personal & Spybot Search & Destroy and when i do my weekly scan for Spyware i also run a eWido Online scan. I would prefer not to have Microsoft Antispyware but in terms of protection if it does a better job then Sbybot then i guest i should but i was just wondering if you was to choose ONLY 1 which one you go for Spybot Search & Destroy or Microsoft Anti Spyware?

[Doe Ray Me]

For anti spyware protection i currently have SpywareBlaster, Ad-ware SE Personal & Spybot Search & Destroy and when i do my weekly scan for Spyware i also run a eWido Online scan. I would prefer not to have Microsoft Antispyware but in terms of protection if it does a better job then Sbybot then i guest i should but i was just wondering if you was to choose ONLY 1 which one you go for Spybot Search & Destroy or Microsoft Anti Spyware?

Microsoft Anti-Spyware, picks up more spyware than Spybot and removes it quickly aswell

[Newhotness]

I've been using SB longer, yet i still think i'd throw my vote to msas, like mentioned above, its found loads more than SB, and the real-time protection seems better aswell.

[englishmen]

You say it removes more spyware but what spyware are you talking about?

[Tarun]

MSAS catches more than Ad-Aware and Spybot. Though Ad-Aware and Spybot get traces MSAS misses. All three are needed regardless.

[Darkman]

Sounds like i would use that Microsoft one also.. but i use ME, not XP.. and they do not make that one for ME

[Andavari]

Sounds like i would use that Microsoft one also.. but i use ME, not XP.. and they do not make that one for ME

Now you know what to ask for as a Christmas present.

[Mike Rochip]

Hello-

My 2 cents worth (due mostly to inflation) is I use the same combo Tarun does and between all 3 hardly anything gets by and they're all easy to configure and use. I didn't use SpyBot that much but since V 1.4 came out it's becoming my favorite. It seems to catch a lot more stuff than previous versions.

The only thing that bugged me about MSAS was that CWS.msconfig sailed right past it pretending to be msconfig.exe.

Seems like with the constant onslaught of new spyware definitions comes ever increasing scan times. I did finally figure out that it helps to have CCleaner and a good firewall to reduce the need to scan so often.

[rridgely]

Mike it sounds like you have been scanning your pc excessively since you got infected. I don't know what your surfing habits are but for me as long as I keep spyware blaster up to date and only use firefox I dont get spyware at all. When I do scan usually once every week or two I only find tracking cookies that I could have gotten rid of with CCleaner.

Also watch out for what you download and you should be all set. Thats just my take on it though but I hate watching spyware scanners all day.

[bpm3k]

Spybot Search & Destroy or Microsoft Anti Spyware?

I do not know why you would not use both.

[berdy]

see here (for patrol comparison)
http://www.dozleng.com/updates/index.php?pg=redundant

[englishmen]

Thanks for all you replies and info guys but i was asking if you was to only use 1 and only 1 regardless if it misses stuff the other one catches. What 1 would you use? I know they are both brilliant apps all tho Microsoft just bought another company and renamed it . But what do you think is the best overall app?

[berdy]

see which area will be patrolled by each one in the link in my post above. I think MSAS covers more if not all.

[Andavari]

Thanks for all you replies and info guys but i was asking if you was to only use 1 and only 1 regardless if it misses stuff the other one catches. What 1 would you use?

Although I don't like MSAS because the GUI is slowish/sluggish, and it ties up my dial-up connection for some minutes I would have to go with it merely for its plethora of resident protection agents. If Microsoft is smart they'll turn MSAS into more than just an anti-spyware program and integrate anti-virus features, and a full featured firewall as well and make it a standard feature of Windows.

[Tarun]

Although I don't like MSAS because the GUI is slowish/sluggish, and it ties up my dial-up connection for some minutes I would have to go with it merely for its plethora of resident protection agents. If Microsoft is smart they'll turn MSAS into more than just an anti-spyware program and integrate anti-virus features, and a full featured firewall as well and make it a standard feature of Windows.

Windows One Care.

[rridgely]

Windows One Care.

Are you beta testing it?

[Capman]

Notice to non-USA residents.

At this time, participation in the Windows OneCare Live Beta is open to U.S. residents only.


Tarun, how do you find out about all this kind of stuff?
Is it from intensive searching?
Or are you a participant of something to do with MS?

[rridgely]

I wonder how much its going to cost.

[Tarun]

Notice to non-USA residents.

At this time, participation in the Windows OneCare Live Beta is open to U.S. residents only.
Tarun, how do you find out about all this kind of stuff?
Is it from intensive searching?
Or are you a participant of something to do with MS?

I'm actually an MS Beta tester. Anyone can check around the web and find info though.

Currently enrolled in:
• Data Protection Manager 2006 - A disk-based solution for data protection and recovery. More Info...
  
• Windows Server 2003 R2 - The core of this release is built on the Windows Server 2003 SP1 platform and adds optionally installable components that our customers have been asking for.
  
• Windows Driver Foundation - The Windows Driver Foundation is a new Windows driver model for both Kernel- and User-mode. It replaces the Windows Driver Framework program as it now includes a User-mode model as well and has subseq...
  
• Installer 6.2 - Beta test of Installer.exe v6.2. (New, better compression.)
  
• MSN Mobile - MSN Mobile Services

[Capman]

I'm actually an MS Beta tester.

I thought it must be something like that.