25 replies to this topic

[xxxxsh4d0wxxxx]

I'm finally getting my new laptop (within 2 weeks or so). Another issue I came across was should I get AMD or Intel? Comments and views on the topic are greatly appreciated.

[rridgely]

Right now intel's core 2 duo chips are the best hands down. They are supposed to be releasing a new line soon that is even better.(more powerful, better battery life) I can't remember the name though.

[JohnDemolition]

i want one of those new ones. they contain SSE4 which is nice due to the new instructions.

as for AMD, forget about it.

[Pfipps]

I'd recommend the new HP Pavilion DV9500's which have the newer Core 2 Duos. However, they only have the top-of-the-line
Intel graphics chip (which is not that fast). If you can wait a little while longer they will either have the Nvidias or ATIs.

[xxxxsh4d0wxxxx]

Wow, I really thought more people would say AMD.

[rridgely]

AMD is in a bad place right now. They merged with ATI who also has been making crappy chips(buy nvidia for sure) and now they can't compete with Intel's processors either.

[xxxxsh4d0wxxxx]

The sad thing is the laptop I am getting comes with an ATI video card.

[rridgely]

Did you already buy it? What kind are you getting?
How much did you pay?

All of these questions could lead to someone showing you a better deal.

[xxxxsh4d0wxxxx]

No, I did not already buy it. I'm getting a Dell Inspiron 1501. However depending if I choose "Home and Home Office" or "Small Business" I then have the choice to chose AMD or Intel. For the one under Home and Home Office it came up to $1060 with AMD.

Intel seems to be a lot more money.. but from all I have researched, AMD seems to have a better "bang for the buck".

EDIT: If I were to get Intel, I would spend the extra money and get the highest upgrade they offer (2.0GHz) as I am with the AMD.

[rridgely]

Its not really about the ghz anymore. Unlike 5 years ago the chip with the highest ghz is not always the "fastest". The intel core 2 duos pretty much blow away anything AMD has. Its been a while since I looked at the Dual Core AMD chips but the Intel's had much better battery life when I looked last(which is a huge factor with a laptop)

Other companies I would look at if I were you are Toshiba(I have a toshiba and its a very solid, well built machine), HP, and IBM.
From what I've read Dell doesn't make bad laptops but they never looked as nice as these other ones.

Also what do you want to be able to do with this laptop? Is it a gaming machine or will it be mainly for MS office work?

[xxxxsh4d0wxxxx]

Mostly web browsing, and gaming.

[rridgely]

How much ram is in the machine your getting?

[xxxxsh4d0wxxxx]

2GB.

[rridgely]

Well I've done a good bit of searching and the best deal I found was this:
http://www.circuitcity.com/ssm/Gateway-15-...roductDetail.do
Plus you get a printer, router, and Webroot security software.

I had a kick ass HP machine picked out(so awesome I almost took out my credit card. ) but then I remembered I don't need a new computer.
It was about 150 more then what you have with dell though.

[xxxxsh4d0wxxxx]

That is a really nice laptop actually.

I'll probably stick with the Dell, but if I decide to reconsider, I know where to look.

Also, for gaming.. it is clearly noted that AMD handles 3D applications better than Intel. The only downside I could find about AMD was shorter battery life, and it generates more heat.

[CTskifreak]

rridgely, on May 26 2007, 11:43 PM, said:

Right now intel's core 2 duo chips are the best hands down. They are supposed to be releasing a new line soon that is even better.(more powerful, better battery life) I can't remember the name though.

PENRYN -- FYI...lol

Intel's Penryn

xxxxsh4d0wxxxx, on May 27 2007, 12:56 PM, said:

That is a really nice laptop actually.

I'll probably stick with the Dell, but if I decide to reconsider, I know where to look.

Also, for gaming.. it is clearly noted that AMD handles 3D applications better than Intel. The only downside I could find about AMD was shorter battery life, and it generates more heat.

Not sure where you found that fact... Intel = Best thing out there. Pair that with a good graphics chip and your good to go. Core 2 Duo's totally pwn AMD's, so don't even think about buying that AMD!

AJ

[rridgely]

What kind of ATI card is it? If its called Radeon xpress something then its a piece of junk.
The reason I say that is because they are onboard graphics meaning that like the intel ones they use system memory for graphics memory. The Intel ones are more compatible with vista from what I've read. (if you notice all of the highend laptops have that intel chip in them. Except for the really expensive ones that have the nvidia go chips)

If you want to do serious gaming on this thing your going to have to spend more money then this anyway. These systems are fast as hell but if gaming is your main aspect then you could get a much much faster desktop for this much money.

[xxxxsh4d0wxxxx]

http://reviews.cnet....-6389077-1.html

It is for desktops, but I'm sure the laptop scene can't be far off.

If I find one for laptops, I'll post it.

Yes, the video card is a Radeon Xpress.

[Anthony A]

xxxxsh4d0wxxxx, on May 27 2007, 12:06 PM, said:

No, I did not already buy it. I'm getting a Dell Inspiron 1501. However depending if I choose "Home and Home Office" or "Small Business" I then have the choice to chose AMD or Intel. For the one under Home and Home Office it came up to $1060 with AMD.

Intel seems to be a lot more money.. but from all I have researched, AMD seems to have a better "bang for the buck".

EDIT: If I were to get Intel, I would spend the extra money and get the highest upgrade they offer (2.0GHz) as I am with the AMD.

My newest laptop is a 17 inch Dell Inspiron. It has 2 gig of ram and a 160 GB hard. My processor is a Intel Core 2 Duo T7400 (2.16 GHz). Other than the fact I had to argue with the clowns to make sure it didn't come preinstalled with junk I have been pretty happy with the Machine.

Why do you think the 2.0 GHz is the highest upgrade they offer? Mine is one up from the one you mentioned and there was another one up from that at 2.33 GHz. If I remember correctly there are 4 Intel Core 2 Duo processors for laptops and the one you mentioned was second from the bottom.

[rridgely]

That article is 2 years old. Things have changed A LOT sence then.
Check out Tom's Hardware for more current info.

Oh and that radeon xpress is worthless. The intel one is way better.